| Action | Repeal and replace 12VAC5-460 and 12VAC5-462 with 12VAC5-461 |
| Stage | NOIRA |
| Comment Period | Ends 12/16/2026 |
![]() |
Thank you for the opportunity to comment on the development of Virginia’s new regulations governing public aquatic facilities.
I support the Commonwealth’s effort to establish consistent statewide safety standards for public aquatic facilities, particularly community, association, condominium, and other pools that may operate without continuous lifeguard supervision.
One area that warrants particular consideration is emergency detection and protective response at facilities operating without continuous lifeguard coverage.
A pool can comply with traditional requirements for fencing, signage, rescue equipment, water quality, and emergency procedures while still having a significant gap: there may be no person actively observing the water when a swimmer experiences an emergency.
I encourage VDH to consider establishing technology-neutral requirements addressing this gap. Regulations could require facilities without continuous lifeguard supervision to maintain reasonable capabilities for:
These requirements should be technology-neutral. They should establish the safety outcome expected rather than mandate a particular technology, vendor, or method. Where appropriate, facilities should be permitted to use trained personnel, technological systems, or combinations of protective measures to satisfy the requirements.
This approach would recognize an important distinction between lifeguard supervision and additional protective-action systems. Technology should not be considered a replacement for a required lifeguard where a lifeguard is otherwise required. However, for facilities that are legally permitted to operate without continuous lifeguard supervision, the Commonwealth should consider whether additional measures are appropriate to reduce the risk of an undetected drowning event.
As Virginia develops the proposed regulations under HB 222, I encourage VDH to specifically evaluate the safety requirements applicable to unguarded community and association pools and to consider whether the regulatory framework adequately addresses the risk of a swimmer becoming submerged when no person is continuously watching the water.
Thank you for considering this comment and for the Department’s work to strengthen aquatic safety throughout Virginia.
Respectfully submitted,
Nathan M.