Virginia Regulatory Town Hall
Agency
Department of Environmental Quality
 
Board
Virginia Waste Management Board
 
chapter
Solid Waste Planning and Recycling Regulations [9 VAC 20 ‑ 130]
Action Regulations for the Development of Solid Waste Management Plans - Amendment 2
Stage Proposed
Comment Period Ended on 1/9/2007
spacer

1 comments

All comments for this forum
Back to List of Comments
1/9/07  12:00 am
Commenter: Harry Gregori

Request Clarification or Change of Definition of Minor and Major Plan Amendment
 
The purpose of the regulation is to provide criteria for the development of a governmental plan to fund and manage waste (Integrated Waste Management Plan).  The current definition of Major amendment indicates that "any" additional facility is to be added to the plan for formal plan amendment.  However, in a free market, particularly for small businesses, the business operation may not be part of the "governments integrated waste management plan" and the requirement to approve private operations as Major amendment is an excessive burden for a small business that are dedicated to the development of waste management programs that move waste upward in the hierarchy, as already provided in the definition of Minor.

There appears to be a conflict in that the definitions of Major and Minor... both indicate "any" change.  Private operations designed to move waste up the hierarchy that are not part of the government plan are viewed by the Department as a Major when the definition of Minor provides for minor changes that move the waste up the hierarchy.

By interpreting the regulations to capture all facilities, the free market is impaired in that the approval of the plan amendment may have no direct relationship to the government's operations.  The process for Major amendment requires an unnecessary burden on small business to complete the processes for the government plan amendment when they provide business activities that move waste up the management hierarchy.  A public review process is already provided in the regulatory processes for public comment and conformance with regulatory limits.

CommentID: 385