| Action | Paid Sick Leave |
| Stage | Proposed |
| Comment Period | Ends 1/1/2027 |
![]() |
5 comments
I am an HR consultant in the Richmond and Hanover County area. Most of the employers I work with are small Virginia businesses. Many have fewer than 50 employees and several have staff in more than one state. I support the goals of the Act and appreciate the detail in the proposed regulation. Clear rules will help small employers get this right the first time.
My comments cover five areas where employers will need more clarity to set their compliance dates and build their policies.
1. Correct the phase-in date in the economic impact analysis.
The Department of Planning and Budget economic impact analysis (Va. Reg. Vol. 43, Iss. 6, p. 591) states that the requirement applies to "employers with at least one employee beginning July 1, 2029." The proposed regulation at 16VAC15-90-30 B 3 and the statute at § 40.1-33.6:1 both set January 1, 2029. I ask that the final rulemaking documents confirm January 1, 2029. Small employers read these materials closely. A conflicting date in the official record will cause confusion about when the smallest employers are covered.
2. State when coverage begins for an employer that crosses a threshold during the year.
Under 16VAC15-90-30 B, an employer counts individuals employed for 20 or more calendar workweeks in the current or preceding calendar year. Because the current year counts, a growing employer could reach a threshold partway through a year. I ask the Department to state when obligations begin in that case.
The options seem to be the date the threshold is met, the start of the employer's next designated year under 16VAC15-90-70 D, or the following January 1. A defined start date with reasonable lead time to set up accrual tracking, the written policy, and employee notices would help growing businesses comply.
3. Explain the basis for counting employees who work outside Virginia.
The proposed rule counts employees in any state or territory of the United States and the District of Columbia. The statute phases in coverage by employer size ("an employer of at least 50 employees") without saying where those employees work. Under the proposed rule, a company with 10 employees in Virginia and 45 in another state is covered on July 1, 2027. A Virginia-only company with 45 employees is not covered until January 1, 2028.
The phase-in appears designed to give smaller operations more time to prepare. A company with a small Virginia presence faces the same setup work as a small Virginia-only company. I ask the Department to explain the statutory basis for a nationwide count in its response to comments. I also ask the Department to consider whether counting only employees who work in Virginia better fits the purpose of the phase-in.
4. Address staffing agency, PEO, and joint employer arrangements.
Many small Virginia employers use a professional employer organization (PEO) or a staffing agency. The proposed rule does not say which entity counts these workers toward the size thresholds.
It also does not say which entity is responsible for accrual, the written policy under 16VAC15-90-70 A, and the notices under 16VAC15-90-90. I ask the Department to address these arrangements in the final rule, consistent with the integrated employer language already in 16VAC15-90-30 A.
5. Confirm who counts as "employed" for the 20-workweek test.
16VAC15-90-30 A states that the Act applies equally to full-time and part-time employees, which suggests that all of them count toward size. I ask the Department to confirm this directly in 16VAC15-90-30 B.
I also ask the Department to address employees in a few common situations: seasonal and temporary employees, employees on leave, employees who separated during the counting period, and employees who were on the payroll during a week but did not work. A clear counting method will help employers near a threshold plan accurately.
Hello and thank you for reviewing my comment.
My first concern is the hardship this will place on many micro businesses and nonprofits. My company is strictly B2B so I hear a lot from others about how the current economy has impacted them. Nonprofits have less resources and fierce competition for grants. They often have 2 - 5 staff members. Micro businesses such as family owned insurance agencies and even my business which has 10 employees will struggle with making this compensation a reality. This is not an indication of whether I feel employees deserve this. It is a statement about the recent poor economy and how it has impacted organizations that are very small. Then, an added requirement to pull out of cash reserves that may not actually exist could put many at risk of going out of business.
A further concern is how employees will be counted for this new law. Of my 10 employees, only 2 are in Virginia. What is my employee count relative to this new law? One is myself, so do the company owners also count? And what about 1 person LLC, how will that fall into this new law? This needs to be clarified in the final language.
Thank you again for the opportunity to submit feedback.
Hello, and thank you for reading my comment and taking my thoughts into consideration.
I am the owner of a small business in rural Virginia with 8 employees, including myself. Three of those employees are nearly full-time; two work approximately 20-25hrs each week, 1 works 15 hours, and the final (besides myself) works 5-10hrs per week. For the 3 nearly full-time staff, I go out of my way to provide them with everything the business can afford - paid vacation, 2-3 days of paid sick leave, paid holidays, paid continuing education - and based on my continuous research, they are paid well. My remaining employees are also paid well and receive holiday pay and bonuses.
The systems I have in place work well for my employees and don't cause undue hardship on my company. I have a very good balance between the business and the employees that I depend on to help me run it. I realize not all employers care about their employees, but government should not mandate this rule across the board. There are way too many "IF"s - items that have yet to be totally worked out and could cause serious hardship for small businesses. Read the previous comments to note the items that are not yet clear enough. In addition, with the economy in the state it's in, you need to boost small businesses, not tear us down even more. Small businesses are the backbone of rural communities. The community supports and depends on us so they don't have to travel to larger towns and cities and pay the higher prices. We, in turn, can keep prices reasonable because we don't try to gouge clients to get rich. With laws being passed mandating small businesses provide "XYZ" to employees, the balance is becoming even more lopsided, which will cause change. The change will not be that employees are better respected, it may be that small businesses will have to charge higher rates to afford the employees. This could cause client loss and, in turn, a need for fewer employees. Or they'll be forced to shutter their doors completely allowing big business to take over.
I know the intentions of these laws, but all the issues are not being considered, and they are being looked at from only one or two angles, not across the whole spectrum of possible effects. Without getting into politics too deeply, please consider what the long-term outcome of these laws may befor ALL and how the already shaky balance of the economy may be affected. Instead of punishing small businesses with laws like these and giving a menial boost to employees, make changes that will have a positive effect on all of society. Fix the misbalance in meaningful ways.
I am writing on behalf of New Kent County to submit a public comment regarding the proposed regulations for Virginia's Paid Sick Leave mandate. Specifically, we respectfully request explicit guidance clarifying whether local governments are required to accrue paid sick leave for individuals who serve solely as Election Day Poll Workers (Officers of Election) on a temporary, fee-for-service or stipend basis.
We ask that you clarify the following two areas:
Clarifying these provisions will prevent inconsistent local interpretations, reduce unnecessary administrative burdens on local electoral boards and ensure full compliance with the law.
Thank you for your time and consideration. Please let me know if our office can provide additional information or context regarding the appointment and compensation of our Election Day workers.
Sincerely,
Margaret Jefferson
Senior Payroll Analyst
New Kent County
804.966.8519
To the Virginia Department of Labor and Industry:
I am the owner of Classic Party Rentals of Virginia, Inc., a Richmond-area event rental company employing approximately 48 people. I am submitting this comment to express concerns about the proposed Paid Sick Leave Regulation, particularly the lack of clear standards governing employee notification requirements, employer accountability, and the consequences of failing to follow established attendance procedures.
Our company already provides paid time off to employees, with additional paid vacation benefits after one year of employment. I recognize the importance of allowing employees to take time off when they are genuinely sick. My concern is not with providing sick leave. It is with creating regulations that may unintentionally remove an employer’s ability to enforce reasonable workplace expectations.
1. Employers Need Enforceable Notification Requirements
Our business operates on strict schedules. We deliver and install equipment for weddings, corporate events, and other functions that cannot simply be postponed because an employee fails to report to work.
When a driver scheduled for 7:00 a.m. calls out at 6:40 a.m., the consequences extend well beyond that employee’s absence. Delivery routes must be rearranged, other employees may be required to work additional hours, and customer commitments may be jeopardized.
We believe employers should be permitted to establish reasonable written notification requirements, such as requiring employees to notify their supervisor at least one hour before their scheduled shift.
The proposed regulation’s reliance on the phrase “as soon as practicable” creates substantial uncertainty about when employees are expected to provide notice and when employers may enforce their policies.
An employee who experiences an unexpected medical emergency should certainly be protected. However, an employee who could reasonably have provided advance notice but simply failed to do so should not automatically receive the same protection from the consequences of violating an established workplace policy.
2. The Regulation Should Clearly Define the Consequences of Improper Notification
We request that the Department clarify whether an employer may deny paid sick leave when an employee fails to comply with a reasonable, previously communicated notification requirement without a legitimate justification.
The regulation should also clearly distinguish between disciplining an employee for taking protected sick leave and disciplining an employee for independently violating a reasonable notification procedure.
These are not the same actions.
Employers need clear guidance on what constitutes an acceptable reason for late notification, what circumstances justify exceptions, and what corrective action is permissible.
Without these standards, businesses face the possibility of enforcement disputes even when attempting in good faith to administer reasonable attendance policies.
3. Small Businesses Cannot Absorb Unlimited Scheduling Disruptions
Unlike businesses where work can be delayed or reassigned over several days, event rental companies must perform services at specific times.
Our delivery drivers, warehouse personnel, and tent installation crews depend on one another. A single unexpected absence can affect an entire crew, require overtime, or force management to perform frontline work.
The cost of paid sick leave is not limited to the wages paid to the absent employee. It also includes replacement labor, overtime, disrupted schedules, reduced productivity, and potentially damaged customer relationships.
I encourage the Department to recognize these operational costs in its economic impact analysis rather than treating the regulation as having no additional adverse effect on small businesses simply because the underlying paid leave requirement was established by statute.
4. Requested Regulatory Clarifications
I respectfully request that the Department:
Closing
Small businesses should not have to choose between protecting employees who are legitimately sick and maintaining reasonable standards of accountability.
We are willing to comply with clear, fair requirements. However, employers need regulations that recognize the realities of operating a business, meeting customer commitments, and managing employees responsibly.
I urge the Department to address these concerns before adopting the final regulation.
Respectfully,
Kurt Whittleton
Owner
Classic Party Rentals of Virginia, Inc.
Richmond, Virginia