Agency
Department of Labor and Industry
 
Board
Department of Labor and Industry
 
chapter
Paid Sick Leave Regulation [16 VAC 15 ‑ 90]
Action Paid Sick Leave
Stage Proposed
Comment Period Ends 1/1/2027
spacer
Previous Comment     Back to List of Comments
11/16/26  10:24 am
Commenter: Kurt Whittleton , Classic Party Rentals of Virginia, Inc.

Public Comment on Proposed Paid Sick Leave Regulation (16VAC15-90)
 

To the Virginia Department of Labor and Industry:

I am the owner of Classic Party Rentals of Virginia, Inc., a Richmond-area event rental company employing approximately 48 people. I am submitting this comment to express concerns about the proposed Paid Sick Leave Regulation, particularly the lack of clear standards governing employee notification requirements, employer accountability, and the consequences of failing to follow established attendance procedures.

Our company already provides paid time off to employees, with additional paid vacation benefits after one year of employment. I recognize the importance of allowing employees to take time off when they are genuinely sick. My concern is not with providing sick leave. It is with creating regulations that may unintentionally remove an employer’s ability to enforce reasonable workplace expectations.

1. Employers Need Enforceable Notification Requirements

Our business operates on strict schedules. We deliver and install equipment for weddings, corporate events, and other functions that cannot simply be postponed because an employee fails to report to work.

When a driver scheduled for 7:00 a.m. calls out at 6:40 a.m., the consequences extend well beyond that employee’s absence. Delivery routes must be rearranged, other employees may be required to work additional hours, and customer commitments may be jeopardized.

We believe employers should be permitted to establish reasonable written notification requirements, such as requiring employees to notify their supervisor at least one hour before their scheduled shift.

The proposed regulation’s reliance on the phrase “as soon as practicable” creates substantial uncertainty about when employees are expected to provide notice and when employers may enforce their policies.

An employee who experiences an unexpected medical emergency should certainly be protected. However, an employee who could reasonably have provided advance notice but simply failed to do so should not automatically receive the same protection from the consequences of violating an established workplace policy.

2. The Regulation Should Clearly Define the Consequences of Improper Notification

We request that the Department clarify whether an employer may deny paid sick leave when an employee fails to comply with a reasonable, previously communicated notification requirement without a legitimate justification.

The regulation should also clearly distinguish between disciplining an employee for taking protected sick leave and disciplining an employee for independently violating a reasonable notification procedure.

These are not the same actions.

Employers need clear guidance on what constitutes an acceptable reason for late notification, what circumstances justify exceptions, and what corrective action is permissible.

Without these standards, businesses face the possibility of enforcement disputes even when attempting in good faith to administer reasonable attendance policies.

3. Small Businesses Cannot Absorb Unlimited Scheduling Disruptions

Unlike businesses where work can be delayed or reassigned over several days, event rental companies must perform services at specific times.

Our delivery drivers, warehouse personnel, and tent installation crews depend on one another. A single unexpected absence can affect an entire crew, require overtime, or force management to perform frontline work.

The cost of paid sick leave is not limited to the wages paid to the absent employee. It also includes replacement labor, overtime, disrupted schedules, reduced productivity, and potentially damaged customer relationships.

I encourage the Department to recognize these operational costs in its economic impact analysis rather than treating the regulation as having no additional adverse effect on small businesses simply because the underlying paid leave requirement was established by statute.

4. Requested Regulatory Clarifications

I respectfully request that the Department:

  1. Explicitly recognize an employer’s right to establish reasonable advance-notification requirements for unforeseeable absences, subject to appropriate exceptions.
  2. Define “as soon as practicable” and provide examples distinguishing unavoidable late notification from an employee’s failure to make a reasonable effort to notify the employer.
  3. Clarify whether an unjustified violation of a properly communicated notification policy may result in denial of paid sick leave.
  4. Clearly establish when employers may impose disciplinary consequences for notification violations without violating the law’s anti-retaliation protections.
  5. Provide practical guidance for businesses with time-sensitive operations where unexpected absences create significant operational and financial consequences.

Closing

Small businesses should not have to choose between protecting employees who are legitimately sick and maintaining reasonable standards of accountability.

We are willing to comply with clear, fair requirements. However, employers need regulations that recognize the realities of operating a business, meeting customer commitments, and managing employees responsibly.

I urge the Department to address these concerns before adopting the final regulation.

Respectfully,

Kurt Whittleton
Owner
Classic Party Rentals of Virginia, Inc.
Richmond, Virginia

 

CommentID: 242891