Agency
Department of Environmental Quality
 
Board
State Water Control Board
 
chapter
Virginia Water Protection Permit Program Regulation [9 VAC 25 ‑ 210]
Action Surface Water Withdrawal Permitting Exclusion for Existing Withdrawals - Amendments to Address Grandfathered Withdrawals
Stage NOIRA
Comment Period Ended on 11/18/2026
spacer
Previous Comment     Next Comment     Back to List of Comments
11/18/26  11:32 am
Commenter: Jamie Goodin, Rockbridge Conservation

Rockbridge Conservation NOIRA Comment
 

Hello,

My name is Jamie Goodin, and I serve as the Executive Director of Rockbridge Conservation, a volunteer-driven nonprofit organization founded in 1976 by a group of concerned citizens committed to protecting our region’s natural and cultural resources. Today, our organization and members contribute thousands of volunteer hours each year toward advancing this important mission.

We believe the Department of Environmental Quality’s plan to take regulatory action on grandfathered surface water withdrawals is a perfect opportunity to address longstanding gaps in Virginia’s oversight of surface water withdrawals, improve water supply planning, and strengthen protections for natural waterways, aquatic life, and the drinking water of our citizens.

While clarifying the existing grandfathered exemption is a necessary step, clarification alone is not sufficient to address the environmental and water resource challenges associated with withdrawals that operate outside our current permitting framework. Virginia must also consider how these withdrawals affect water availability, aquatic ecosystems, and the Commonwealth’s ability to manage its water resources sustainably.  Therefore, we are asking that you include in this regulatory action the following three items:

1. Virginia should address the long-term exemption of grandfathered withdrawals.

Grandfathered surface water withdrawals have operated outside the VWP permitting framework for nearly four decades.  According to your own account, approximately 81% of Virginia’s total surface water withdrawals are associated with unpermitted facilities.

Although state law requires a VWP permit for increases in withdrawal amounts, ambiguity surrounding how increases are measured has created opportunities for facilities to claim continued grandfathered status based on intake capacity rather than actual historical withdrawal volumes. In fact, some facilities have reportedly increased withdrawals by 100% or more without obtaining a VWP permit.

Virginia should take the necessary statutory steps to bring grandfathered and other unpermitted surface water withdrawals into an appropriate permitting framework. The current regulatory process should not be limited to clarifying an exemption that has allowed significant withdrawals to remain outside modern environmental review for decades.

2. Establish clear, enforceable interim safeguards.

While broader statutory changes are considered, DEQ should establish clear and enforceable safeguards for existing grandfathered withdrawals. These should include:

  • Defining withdrawal limits based on documented historical withdrawal volumes rather than intake capacity.

  • Establishing transparent, enforceable limits on withdrawal amounts.

  • Strengthening permitting triggers for increases in withdrawal volumes.

  • Clarifying how abandonment, changes in use, and transfers of ownership affect grandfathered status.

  • Requiring adequate documentation and reporting to support accurate water resource planning and regulatory oversight.

3. Explicitly address impacts to aquatic life and river ecosystems.

A significant concern with grandfathered withdrawals is the lack of environmental review and aquatic life protections comparable to those required through the VWP permitting process.

Surface water intakes can cause direct mortality of aquatic organisms through entrainment, when fish eggs, larvae, and other small organisms are drawn into intake infrastructure, and impingement, when fish become trapped against intake screens.

These impacts can be particularly harmful to native and migratory fish populations, as well as threatened and endangered species, including species identified as Virginia species of greatest conservation need.  In short, aquatic life protections should be a central component of this regulatory process, not a secondary consideration.

The Regulatory Advisory Panel (RAP) should explicitly examine:

  • Entrainment and impingement impacts associated with existing surface water intakes.

  • Cumulative impacts of multiple withdrawals within individual watersheds.

  • Impacts during droughts and low-flow conditions.

  • Potential effects on threatened and endangered species and Virginia species of greatest conservation need.

  • Opportunities to require protective technologies, operational changes, and other mitigation measures at existing intakes.

  • Regulatory protections and any additional statutory authority necessary to address these impacts.

With much of the Commonwealth experiencing ongoing extreme drought and the growing threats posed by climate change, Rockbridge Conservation urges you to seize this opportunity to better protect our water resources, the ecosystems they sustain, and the people who depend on them.

 

CommentID: 242922