| Action | Surface Water Withdrawal Permitting Exclusion for Existing Withdrawals - Amendments to Address Grandfathered Withdrawals |
| Stage | NOIRA |
| Comment Period | Ended on 11/18/2026 |
![]() |
17 November 2026
Morgan Emanuel
Regulatory and Guidance Analyst
Virginia Department of Environmental Quality
Re: Comments on NOIRA for Surface Water Withdrawal Permitting Exclusion for Existing Withdrawals Amendments to Address Grandfathered Withdrawals
Dear Mr. Emanuel:
Thank you for the opportunity to provide comments on the regulatory review concerning grandfathered surface water withdrawals. The James River Association (JRA) is a member-supported nonprofit organization founded in 1976 to serve as a guardian and voice for the James River. Throughout the James River’s 10,000-square mile watershed, JRA works toward its vision of a fully healthy James River supporting thriving communities. Our thousands of members and supporters have important economic, professional, and personal interests in the health of the James River, and we are pleased to offer a voice for the River and its stakeholders.
JRA supports the Department of Environmental Quality's (DEQ) efforts to clarify the existing exemption for surface water withdrawals in operation before July 1, 1989. We remain concerned that grandfathered withdrawals, in addition to the many other exempted and unpermitted withdrawals in Virginia, operate outside the Virginia Water Protection (VWP) permitting framework, limiting DEQ's ability to ensure adequate protections for aquatic life and other beneficial uses of the Commonwealth’s surface water resources. We are supportive of having grandfathered withdrawals brought into the VWP permitting system to ensure that they are managed responsibly and do not compromise the health of Virginia's rivers and aquatic ecosystems.
Virginia's recent historic drought conditions underscore the need for clear standards and effective management of competing water demands. These challenges are longstanding. In 2016, the Joint Legislative Audit and Review Commission (JLARC) identified significant uncertainty surrounding grandfathered withdrawals and recommended clarifying permitting triggers and withdrawal amounts. Nearly a decade later, these issues remain unresolved.
While JRA believes that ultimately ending the grandfathered exemption and requiring all unpermitted withdrawals to obtain VWP permits would provide the most comprehensive protections to beneficial uses and aquatic life in the Commonwealth, we recognize that this NOIRA seeks to clarify the existing statutory framework rather than eliminate it. We urge DEQ to use this process to establish clear, enforceable standards within its authority, strengthen protections for aquatic life and water resources, and identify any statutory changes necessary to address remaining gaps.
JRA offers the following comments and recommendations:
1) Grandfathered Withdrawal Amounts Should Be Based on Historical Water Use Rather than Intake Capacity
Under § 62.1-44.15:22(B) of the Code of Virginia, surface water withdrawals in existence on July 1, 1989, are exempt from VWP permitting requirements; however, a permit is required if a new § 401 certification is required to increase a withdrawal. Despite this, some grandfathered water withdrawals have more than doubled the volume of their historic usage as reported prior to 1989.
If grandfathering these water withdrawals in any form is to continue, JRA strongly supports defining grandfathered withdrawal amounts based on historical water use rather than the physical capacity of intake structures. Interpreting the exemption based on intake capacity could allow facilities to substantially increase withdrawals beyond historical levels without undergoing VWP environmental review or demonstrating that additional withdrawals will not adversely affect aquatic life, downstream water users, or other beneficial uses.
JLARC specifically examined this issue in 2016, documenting significant disagreements between DEQ and grandfathered withdrawal operators about the quantities of water covered by the exemption. In one example, JLARC identified a 329-million-gallon-per-day difference between the amount a major public water supplier believed it could withdraw and the amount DEQ believed appropriate. As such, JRA urges DEQ to ensure that the revised regulations do not allow hypothetical withdrawal capacity to become the basis for grandfathered withdrawal rights.
The importance of establishing clear withdrawal amounts is further demonstrated by DEQ's 2020 State Water Resources Plan, which found that a scenario modeling maximum possible demands from exempt surface water users would exceed the available water budget in many Virginia streams and rivers. This finding raises concerns about water availability during drought and the state's ability to manage competing demands.
JRA urges DEQ to establish a consistent methodology for determining grandfathered withdrawal amounts based on documented historical use. The RAP should clarify when increased withdrawals require permitting and identify any statutory changes necessary to establish enforceable withdrawal limits.
2) The Regulatory Process Must Consider the Impacts of Grandfathered Withdrawals on Aquatic Life
JRA's chief concern is the impact of grandfathered withdrawals on aquatic organisms, including Virginia’s vulnerable migratory fish species that rely on our rivers for spawning, migration, and nursery habitat. Surface water intake structures can cause mortality through impingement, when fish become trapped against intake screens, and entrainment, when organisms, including fish eggs and larvae, are drawn into intake systems. These impacts are particularly concerning for American shad, river herring, and federally endangered Atlantic sturgeon; all species which are imperiled, depleted, and/or endangered.
American shad, once a cornerstone of the Commonwealth’s fisheries and an important food source for generations of Virginians and Tribal Nations, have declined dramatically, with James River populations remaining at 0% of the Chesapeake Bay Program's recovery goal since 2021. The 2023 Framework for the Recovery of American Shad in the James River identifies grandfathered and unpermitted water intakes as a potential threat to recovery, noting that their individual and cumulative impacts remain poorly understood. Similarly, Virginia’s 2021 American Shad Habitat Plan identifies water intakes among threats to shad habitat and calls for improved understanding of intake impacts, particularly in tidal spawning and nursery areas.
Studies demonstrate the potential scale of intake-related mortality. A 2021 analysis of Chesterfield Power Station estimated that its intake alone could entrain approximately 1.67 billion finfish and 106 million shellfish annually under modeled operating conditions. A 2024 Virginia Institute of Marine Science (VIMS) modeling assessment of three proximately located intake structures on the Appomattox River estimated individual impacts on fish larval mortality of less than 1%, but cumulative mortality of the three intakes of up to 7.5% for the system. These findings illustrate the importance of evaluating both individual and cumulative impacts and ensuring that withdrawals are subject to appropriate safeguards.
Virginia has established approaches to reducing these impacts through the VWP permitting process. The Department of Wildlife Resources (DWR) 2025 Virginia Wildlife Action Plan explicitly identifies surface water withdrawals as a threat to American shad, alewife, and blueback herring and recommends appropriate intake placement, seasonal operating restrictions, and best practices for intake designs. DWR has also developed recommended intake design and operation standards addressing screening, intake velocities, and minimum flows to prevent impingement and entrainment. As part of VWP permitting, DEQ evaluates impacts on aquatic life and other beneficial uses and can establish protective conditions, including withdrawal limits and minimum instream flows. However, grandfathered withdrawals are not subject to these requirements of the permit issuance process.
Importantly, 9VAC25-210-310(B) allows DEQ to require certain otherwise exempt withdrawals to obtain permits when they significantly impair fish and wildlife resources, individually or in combination with other withdrawals. Grandfathered withdrawals under subsection A(1) are excluded from this provision, leaving a significant gap in the protections available for aquatic life. Of the more than 300 withdrawals that Virginia grandfathered this way, concerns for aquatic life impacts exist regardless of whether their withdrawal volumes have increased.
JRA urges DEQ to ensure that the Regulatory Advisory Panel (RAP):
JRA also encourages DEQ to coordinate with NOAA Fisheries regarding grandfathered withdrawals that may affect federally protected species, particularly Atlantic sturgeon in Virginia's tidal rivers. Grandfathered status does not exempt facilities from the federal Endangered Species Act, and additional federal authorizations or protective measures may be necessary where operations result in incidental take of listed species. Virginia’s VWP program has analogous threatened and endangered species protections, which are another absent consideration for unpermitted water withdrawals in Virginia.
Aquatic life protections must be a central component of the RAP's work as it considers how grandfathered withdrawals are quantified, managed, and regulated.
3) DEQ Should Clarify Abandonment, Changes in Use, and the Circumstances Under Which Grandfathered Status Is Maintained
JRA supports DEQ's efforts to clarify the existing regulations governing abandonment and permitting responsibility. Under 9VAC25-210-310(A)(1)(a), a grandfathered withdrawal is considered abandoned when an owner notifies DEQ of abandonment or removes or disables the withdrawal system with the intent to permanently cease withdrawals. The regulations explicitly state that transfers of ownership or operational control, changes in water use, and temporary cessation do not constitute abandonment.
JRA encourages DEQ to reevaluate these provisions to ensure that grandfathered status is not maintained indefinitely for withdrawals that are no longer actively used. The regulations should establish clear and reasonable criteria for determining abandonment, including how extended periods of nonuse are evaluated. Similarly, this RAP should also examine the implications of transferring grandfathered withdrawal rights to new owners or operators, particularly when facilities undergo substantial changes in operations or water use.
As demand for Virginia's water resources increases, the ability to acquire an existing grandfathered withdrawal without undergoing VWP permitting review presents concerns for future water management and foregone environmental and wildlife protections. The RAP should identify the statutory amendments necessary to address these risks as a part of this regulatory action.
4) DEQ Should Identify Statutory Changes Needed to Address Remaining Gaps in Grandfathered Withdrawal Oversight to Protect Virginia’s Water Resources and Beneficial Uses
JRA recognizes that this NOIRA is intended to clarify the existing statutory exemption. Nevertheless, the scale of grandfathered withdrawals and limitations of existing regulatory oversight underscore the need for broader statutory reform. Uncertainty surrounding the quantities of water that grandfathered facilities may claim as exempt creates challenges for evaluating water availability, protecting downstream beneficial uses, and planning for periods of drought and increasing water demand. Accurate reporting and clear withdrawal limits are essential to protecting water supplies, downstream users, and aquatic ecosystems during drought.
JRA believes that the Commonwealth should ultimately establish a reasonable, phased transition of grandfathered and unpermitted surface water withdrawals into the VWP permitting framework, or analogous protections for surface waters and aquatic life, while accounting for public water supply needs and continuity of service.
We encourage DEQ and the RAP to explore such a transition and to identify statutory changes needed to address gaps through the current regulatory process, including permitting triggers, withdrawal limits, transfers of ownership or operational control, and protections for aquatic life.
5) The Regulatory Advisory Panel Must Include Representation from Conservation and Fisheries Interests
The informal workgroup convened by DEQ in 2024 consisted primarily of grandfathered withdrawal operators and did not reach consensus on recommended changes. DEQ has now identified a RAP as the mechanism for developing proposed regulatory amendments. Given the implications of grandfathered withdrawals for Virginia's water resources, the RAP must include a balanced range of perspectives. JRA urges DEQ to include representatives of Virginia's Tribal Nations, conservation organizations, fisheries and aquatic ecology experts, and downstream water users alongside grandfathered withdrawal operators.
JRA formally requests participation in the RAP and welcomes the opportunity to contribute our expertise in river conservation, aquatic life protections, and water resource management.
Conclusion
Virginia's rivers provide critical habitat for aquatic organisms, support drinking water supplies and economic activity, and serve communities throughout the Commonwealth. Historic declines of migratory fish, recent drought conditions, and DEQ's own water supply modeling underscore the importance of managing water supply with a clear understanding of existing demands and the need to protect our natural resources.
DEQ's regulatory process presents an important opportunity to address longstanding ambiguities surrounding grandfathered surface water withdrawals. JRA urges DEQ to establish a clear framework for quantifying grandfathered withdrawals based on historical use, strengthen oversight within its existing authority, and ensure that aquatic life protections are a central focus of the RAP's work.
Thank you for your consideration of these comments. JRA looks forward to working with DEQ and other stakeholders to advance water management policies that protect the James River and Virginia's aquatic resources.
Sincerely,
Shannon Orcutt
Government Affairs and Policy Manager
James River Association