Agency
Department of Environmental Quality
 
Board
State Water Control Board
 
chapter
Virginia Water Protection Permit Program Regulation [9 VAC 25 ‑ 210]
Action Surface Water Withdrawal Permitting Exclusion for Existing Withdrawals - Amendments to Address Grandfathered Withdrawals
Stage NOIRA
Comment Period Ended on 11/18/2026
spacer
Previous Comment     Next Comment     Back to List of Comments
11/17/26  2:21 pm
Commenter: Jess Kraus, Potomac Riverkeeper Network

Comment of Potomac Riverkeeper Network re: Grandfathered Surface Water Withdrawals NOIRA
 

Morgan Emanuel

Regulatory and Guidance Analyst

Department of Environmental Quality

 

November 17, 2026

 

Comment of Potomac Riverkeeper Network re: Grandfathered Surface Water Withdrawals Notice of Intended Regulatory Action

 

The Potomac Riverkeeper Network (“PRKN”) submits this comment on the Notice of Intended Regulatory Action (“NOIRA”) concerning amendments to section 9VAC25-210 et. seq. of the Virginia Administrative Code regarding grandfathered surface water withdrawals, noticed on October 19, 2026, for which the comment period runs through November 18, 2026.

 

PRKN’s mission is to protect the right to clean water for all communities and all those who live in and rely upon the Potomac and Shenandoah watersheds by stopping pollution, making drinking water safe, protecting healthy river habits, and enhancing use and enjoyment for all. Approximately 3.2 million Virginians rely upon the Potomac and Shenandoah rivers for drinking water, recreation, aquatic ecosystems, and more. PRKN is a stakeholder to this rulemaking because the vast majority of water withdrawals in our watersheds are wholly unregulated, putting at risk stream flows and the designated uses dependent upon in-stream quantity.

 

Grandfathered surface water withdrawals represent approximately 80% of the surface water withdrawals in the Commonwealth and remain unregulated and outside the scope of DEQ’s Virginia Water Protection (“VWP”) permitting. This issue is amplified by the fact that current regulations remain vague and ill-equipped to address the impacts of increased withdrawals performed by these grandfathered water systems. With limited ability to monitor and regulate the majority of surface water withdrawals, DEQ is unable to fulfill its charge of safeguarding the environment and supporting the health and wellbeing of the public.

 

Of great concern to PRKN is the quantity of unregulated intakes located within the Potomac and Shenandoah watersheds, putting these rivers and the beneficial users of them at severe risk. For example, the towns of Front Royal and Strasburg in the Shenandoah watershed have instituted water restrictions since 2023 due to drought conditions. Other impacts include reduced passability for boating and changes in thermal quality necessary for conservation purposes. Without the ability to monitor and regulate grandfathered surface water withdrawals, these impacts may continue to increase in severity.

 

Of the approximately 1,112 surface water withdrawals reported by DEQ in 2025, which includes both permitted and unpermitted withdrawals, 255 occurred in the Potomac and Shenandoah watersheds. That comprises approximately 23% of the total number of surface water withdrawals occurring in the Commonwealth. Of those 255 withdrawals, only 15, or approximately 6%, are permitted. As a result, the vast majority of surface water withdrawals occurring in the Potomac and Shenandoah watersheds are grandfathered or otherwise unpermitted.

 

Additionally, approximately 93% of the surface water withdrawn in the Potomac and Shenandoah watersheds is being used for “public water supply uses”. This category of use almost certainly includes industrial users of public water utilities, such as data centers. These grandfathered water utilities exacerbate the issue of inadequate monitoring and tracking of the exponential growth of water demand from data centers as well as other sectors of private use of the public’s surface water resources.

 

Regulatory reporting requirements serve a critical and fundamental role in DEQ’s ability to protect our waterways. Under the current regulatory scheme, DEQ is unable to ascertain how much water is being withdrawn by grandfathered users or when those withdrawals occur. The NOIRA as written does not address this issue. This lack of enforcement ability could have disastrous impacts on the Potomac and Shenandoah rivers. These rivers are some of the most important in the Commonwealth due to the number of users, their proximity to uses of national significance, and their ecological impacts. The lack of permitting and regulatory enforcement of the vast majority of water intakes occurring in these watersheds makes it nearly impossible to ensure adequate and safe use and enjoyment of the Potomac and Shenandoah Rivers.

 

The NOIRA seeks to only clarify the language that defines the grandfathered surface water withdrawals. While clarity in the regulatory process is important, it does not address the larger issues that grandfathered surface water withdrawals create. Without having the ability to monitor the amount of surface water being withdrawn, DEQ lacks the data and enforcement tools necessary to ensure that waterways, including the Potomac and Shenandoah Rivers, maintain the requisite water quantity for all beneficial users.

 

Water quality and environmental health are also concerns, as these grandfathered systems are not required to follow best practices that they otherwise would if they fell within the VWP permitting framework. This has impacts on aquatic ecosystems and the health and quality of the rivers and watersheds in which these intakes are located. In the Potomac River, we have already seen the potential impact of entrainment and impingement on fisheries, particularly commercial fisheries that have experienced record low landings in recent years.[1] Without permitting requirements, grandfathered users are not required to implement best practices that have proven effective at decreasing entrainment and impingement issues. 

 

Additionally, the Shenandoah River is prone to harmful algae blooms (“HAB”s), including a 52.5 mile HAB alert in 2021 on the North Fork of the Shenandoah that reached from Front Royal to Edinburgh. HABs have been documented to cause harm to human health, pets, and livestock. HABs form from a combination of high nutrients in the river and low water quantity. The lower the water levels, the more residency time increases, and the higher the water temperature gets. This combination of factors creates the ideal environment for HAB growth, as well as other waterborne pathogens. The unregulated and unmonitored withdrawal of surface water by grandfathered users exacerbates existing challenges of low water levels already facing communities within these watersheds.

 

Not only do grandfathered surface withdrawals create quantifiable and measurable harm to human and environmental health, they also create equity concerns and disparities. Water law in the Commonwealth is founded on the principle of “riparian rights”, as opposed to the “prior appropriation” or “first in time, first in right” principle used in other states. Under the “prior appropriation” principle, whoever first diverts water from the river for a beneficial use has the priority in water intake, oftentimes irrespective of downstream impacts. However, under the “riparian rights” principle, reasonable use of the river is allocated proportionally to riverfront property owners along the entire length of the water body. Perpetual grandfathering of surface water withdrawals that existed prior to 1989 runs in the face of this “riparian rights” principle. In fact, it more closely supports the “prior appropriation” principle that Virginia has never adopted. Allowing these grandfathered intakes to persist unpermitted and unregulated simply because they existed first prioritizes their use over other beneficial uses that may provide a higher and better use and greater public benefit. This is evidenced by the municipal water restrictions put in place on the Shenandoah River as grandfathered industrial and agricultural uses continue their unrestricted withdrawals from the river.

 

Therefore, PRKN calls for the following actions by DEQ regarding this NOIRA:

 

  • End grandfathering: Virginia should take the necessary statutory steps to bring unpermitted withdrawals into the VWP permitting framework. Clarifying the existing exemption is not the same as ending it. The owners of grandfathered and unpermitted surface water withdrawals have enjoyed avoiding the state’s permitting scheme for nearly 40 years and this needs to be addressed to plan for the Commonwealth’s present and future growth and sustainability.

 

  • Strengthen interim safeguards: Establish clear, enforceable limits on grandfathered withdrawal volumes and strengthen permitting triggers for increased withdrawals. Reevaluate how abandonment, changes in use, and transfers of ownership affect grandfathered status.

 

  • Protect rivers and aquatic life: Ensure the Regulatory Advisory Panel (RAP) explicitly examines the impacts of unpermitted withdrawals on aquatic life, including entrainment, impingement, cumulative impacts, and low-flow conditions. Evaluate options for requiring protective measures at existing intakes and identify regulatory protections and any additional statutory authority needed to address these impacts, with an eye for protecting threatened, endangered species, and VAs species of greatest conservation need.

 

  • Ensure balanced RAP representation: Include Tribal Nations, conservation organizations, fisheries experts, and downstream water users alongside grandfathered withdrawal operators. The RAP should meaningfully consider aquatic life protections when developing its recommendations.

 

To ensure representation of the Potomac and Shenandoah watersheds, PRKN requests consideration for acceptance on the Regulatory Advisory Panel associated with this NOIRA. Thank you for your consideration in amending the NOIRA to ensure the best possible outcome for our rivers, watersheds, and the people and ecosystems that rely on them.

 

Sincerely,

 

 

Jess Kraus                                                                  Madeleine Green

Staff Attorney                                                              Virginia Campaign Coordinator

Potomac Riverkeeper Network                                   Potomac Riverkeeper Network

jess@prknetwork.org                                                  madeleine@prknetwork.org



[1] Potomac River Fisheries Commission, Preliminary Commercial Finfish Landings for 2025, published April 1, 2026.

CommentID: 242912