| Action | Surface Water Withdrawal Permitting Exclusion for Existing Withdrawals - Amendments to Address Grandfathered Withdrawals |
| Stage | NOIRA |
| Comment Period | Ended on 11/18/2026 |
![]() |
November 18, 2026
Morgan Emanuel
Regulatory and Guidance Analyst
Virginia Department of Environmental Quality
Re: NOIRA - Surface Water Withdrawal Permitting Exclusion for Existing Withdrawals, Amendments to Address Grandfathered Withdrawals
Dear Mr. Emanuel:
Founded in 1972, the Piedmont Environmental Council (PEC) is a community-supported 501(c)(3) nonprofit and accredited land trust operating in a nine-county region in Virginia. PEC works to protect and restore the lands and waters of the Virginia Piedmont, specifically by promoting healthy waterways, wildlife habitat restoration and the productivity of our agricultural lands.
We have long been involved in conservation work in our watersheds; the Potomac and Rappahannock in particular. Access to adequate clean water for residents, farmers and small businesses is paramount to public health and well-being. The current state of Virginia’s water resources calls for urgency. The public’s water needs must take precedence over the needs of data centers or other water-consumptive industries. It is with these priorities in mind that PEC respectfully submits the following comments.
Grandfathered withdrawals remain outside modern permitting requirements. 81% of Virginia’s total surface water withdrawals are unpermitted facilities. While state law requires a VWP permit to increase a withdrawal, ambiguity in how grandfathered withdrawals increases are defined has enabled some facilities to claim exemptions based on intake capacity rather than historical withdrawal volumes. Some facilities have increased withdrawals by 100% or more without obtaining a VWP permit.
Challenges to water supply planning. Unclear withdrawal limits and incomplete information make it harder to assess water availability and cumulative impacts, with potentially dire consequences during drought and low-flow conditions.
Inadequate protections for aquatic life. Grandfathered water withdrawals are not subject to the same environmental review and aquatic life protections required through VWP permitting. At a time when native species like Virginia’s migratory fish are facing substantial population declines, protections are needed to prevent wildlife mortality via entrainment of eggs and larvae and the impingement of fish on intake screens and infrastructure.
PEC therefore joins other conservation partners and calls for the following:
End grandfathering. Virginia should take the necessary statutory steps to bring unpermitted withdrawals into the VWP permitting framework. Clarifying the existing exemption is not the same as ending it. The owners of grandfathered and unpermitted surface water withdrawals have enjoyed avoiding the state’s permitting scheme for nearly 40 years and this needs to be addressed to plan for the Commonwealth’s future.
Strengthen interim safeguards. Establish clear, enforceable limits on grandfathered withdrawal volumes and strengthen permitting triggers for increased withdrawals. Reevaluate how abandonment, changes in use, and transfers of ownership affect grandfathered status.
Protect rivers and aquatic life. Ensure the Regulatory Advisory Panel (RAP) explicitly examines the impacts of unpermitted withdrawals on aquatic life, including entrainment, impingement, cumulative impacts, and low-flow conditions. Evaluate options for requiring protective measures at existing intakes and identify regulatory protections and any additional statutory authority needed to address these impacts, with an eye for protecting threatened, endangered species, and species of greatest conservation need.
Ensure balanced RAP representation. Include Tribal Nations, conservation organizations, fisheries experts, and downstream water users alongside grandfathered withdrawal operators. The RAP should meaningfully consider aquatic life protections when developing its recommendations.
DEQ's regulatory process is an opportunity to strengthen oversight of grandfathered surface water withdrawals, improve water supply planning, and address impacts on rivers and aquatic life. The RAP should identify clear, enforceable safeguards and recommend any additional statutory changes needed to protect Virginia's water resources and aquatic life.
Respectfully submitted,
Don McCown
Land Use Field Representative
Piedmont Environmental Council