| Action | Surface Water Withdrawal Permitting Exclusion for Existing Withdrawals - Amendments to Address Grandfathered Withdrawals |
| Stage | NOIRA |
| Comment Period | Ended on 11/18/2026 |
![]() |
18 November 2026
Morgan Emanuel
Regulatory and Guidance Analyst
Virginia Department of Environmental Quality
Re: Comments on NOIRA for Surface Water Withdrawal Permitting Exclusion for Existing Withdrawals Amendments to Address Grandfathered Withdrawals
Dear Mr. Emanuel:
Thank you for the opportunity to provide comments on the NOIRA for Surface Water Withdrawal Permitting Exclusion for Existing Withdrawals Amendments to Address Grandfathered Withdrawals. Friends of the Rappahannock (FOR) is a 501c3 watershed conservation organization whose mission is to be the voice and active force for a healthy and scenic Rappahannock River.
FOR appreciates the Virginia Department of Environmental Quality's (DEQ) proactive efforts to clarify the existing exemption for surface water withdrawals in operation before July 1, 1989. We remain concerned that grandfathered withdrawals, in addition to the many other exempted and unpermitted withdrawals in Virginia, operate outside the Virginia Water Protection (VWP) permitting framework, limiting DEQ's ability to ensure adequate protections for aquatic life and other beneficial uses of the Commonwealth’s surface water resources. Notably, the NOIRA does not propose to end grandfathering nor will it address other exempted, unpermitted surface water withdrawals.
These issues become more urgent given the current state of Virginia’s water resources. Groundwater resources across the Commonwealth are in decline from overuse and lack of recharge due to extended periods of minimal precipitation. Surface water flows have experienced all time lows while facing increased pressure for withdrawals due to localities looking for alternative water sources as they seek to reduce reliance on groundwater wells. The data center industry now seeks access to Virginia’s water resources while using cooling technologies that consume up to 60% of the cooling water they are provided. This loss leads to reduced flows into Virginia's waterways.
DEQ initiated an informal workgroup in August 2024 composed primarily of entities with grandfathered withdrawals to discuss the current interpretation and implementation of the exclusion in § 62.1-44.15:22 of the Code of Virginia. Unfortunately, this informal workgroup did not include a broad array of stakeholders and the active participants failed to agree to any proactive measures. Modeling presented during these meetings by DEQ staff found that “the cumulative maximum possible [water] demands for exempt surface water users would exceed the available water budget in many of Virginia’s streams and rivers.” This establishes a need for clear, enforceable limits on grandfathered withdrawal volumes and strengthen permitting triggers for increased withdrawals.
Thankfully, DEQ plans to form a Regulatory Advisory Panel (RAP) that should comprise a balanced range of perspectives. These should include representatives of Virginia's Tribal Nations, conservation organizations, fisheries and aquatic ecology experts, and downstream water users alongside grandfathered withdrawal operators.
FOR respectfully requests to be a part of the RAP given the impacts unpermitted surface water intakes have on the Rappahannock River, the poor state of our migratory fisheries and the proliferation of data centers being built in our watershed.
In addition to clarifying the existing exemption for surface water withdrawals in operation before July 1, 1989 we recommend taking the necessary statutory steps to bring unpermitted withdrawals into the VWP permitting framework. The owners of grandfathered and unpermitted surface water withdrawals have enjoyed avoiding the state’s permitting scheme for nearly 40 years and this needs to be addressed to plan for the Commonwealth’s water resource future.
FOR understands the time and resources required to undertake this process and is committed to working with DEQ and stakeholders to ensure these resources are provided and a clear path is established to bring unpermitted and grandfathered intake owners into the permitted realm.
The NOIRA process must protect rivers and aquatic life by examining the impacts of unpermitted withdrawals on aquatic life, including entrainment, impingement, cumulative impacts, and low-flow conditions. VIMS staff should be consulted as they are currently undertaking a study on the cumulative impacts of surface water intakes on aquatic fauna and salinity migration in the James, York, and Rappahannock Rivers.
FOR appreciates the opportunity to submit these comments and look forward to working with all stakeholders to ensure Virginia’s water resources are available to all beneficial users in the future.
Respectfully submitted,
Brent Hunsinger
Director of Advocacy and Coastal Programs
Friends of the Rappahannock