Virginia Regulatory Town Hall
Agency
Virginia Department of Health
 
Board
State Board of Health
 
chapter
Regulations for Alternative Onsite Sewage Systems [12 VAC 5 ‑ 613]
Action Action to Adopt Regulations for Alternative Onsite Sewage Systems
Stage Proposed
Comment Period Ended on 2/4/2011
spacer
Previous Comment     Next Comment     Back to List of Comments
2/2/11  4:09 pm
Commenter: Peter M. Brooks, PE, AOSE; Principal, PMBA Environemtal Services

50% TN reduction for Cheasapeake Bay
 

Typ. domestic wastwater TN concentrations reange between 20-85 mg/l with a medium value of 40 mg/l.  A 50% TN concentration, therefore,  must reduce concentration beflow  20 mg/l if permit discharge standards are to be meet. In my professiional judgement, no TL-2 system is designed to meet  this standard and could not be used in the Cheaspeake Bay area without additional treatment processes added after the system. 

A significant number of water sources in the affected area may lack sufficient alkalinity to achieve 50% TN removal. The most common BAT to supply alkalinity is the use of chemical treatment of either the wastewater or water source to meet process demands. VHD, in my opinion,  has greatly underestimated the construction and o+m cost s associated with the proposed standard by ignoring the variability in water sources in the Cheasapeake Bay watershed. 

CommentID: 14999