16 comments
Requiring QMHP practitioners to have another team member present in-person on MCR dispatches will put a burden on an already-taxed workforce. Team-compositions should be allowed to to function in a hybrid in-person and telehealth capacity.
In an already intense staffing shortage for licensed professional mental health providers requiring this level of professional licensure will burden a severely burdened system and reduce access to care. This is not a sustainable thought while good intentioned and figuring out alternative ways to enhance service delivery models should be considered.
Separating the supplemental coding for TDO is an important step in ensuring that every service that is being provided to a PIC (person in crisis) is able to explore the billing needs to ensure that quality staffing can be hired is critical to service delivery which enhances the experience or the PIC and ensures support. TDO reimbursement rate being reduced to 4hours is not conducive to the workflow that occurs for TDO processes and due to amount of time spent when managing a critical need needs to be considered. It should remain that the 8hr supplement in order to provide the proper service delivery model of care.
The State of Virginia should take over providing MCR Services providers no longer want to provide it seeing that MCO's are not reimbursing for services.
The ECO period is 8 hours and very rarely are practitioners able to find a bed during this time period. Work being done includes the assessment, collaterol, documenting, working with medical professionals and working to find placement. Four hours is not sufficient for this to occur.
As a behavioral health provider, I strongly believe that four hours is simply not sufficient to adequately respond to an individual experiencing a mental health crisis. De-escalation is not something that should be rushed or measured solely by a time limit. Providers must have adequate time to establish rapport, stabilize the individual, conduct a thorough assessment, complete all required service delivery components, coordinate care, develop a meaningful safety plan, and facilitate an appropriate step-down or transition to ongoing services.
We cannot continue to emphasize quality care while creating systems that make it increasingly difficult for providers to deliver that care effectively.
Additionally, there needs to be greater accountability and oversight of Managed Care Organizations (MCOs) and their compliance with DMAS regulations, particularly regarding authorizations, reimbursement practices, and payment denials. Many providers are experiencing significant reimbursement challenges after delivering medically necessary crisis services in good faith. Sentara being the main one.
At the time of dispatch, MCOs should be able to provide providers with accurate, real-time information regarding an individual's authorization status and whether another provider is already delivering or authorized to deliver the same service. For example, providers have experienced situations involving Anthem where they were unable to identify an existing provider authorization, resulting in duplicate authorizations and subsequent claim denials. This raises serious concerns, especially for services designed to provide an immediate response to individuals in crisis.
In my professional opinion, DMAS should strongly consider removing the management of Mobile Crisis Response (MCR) services from MCOs and overseeing these services directly through Medicaid. At a minimum, the current authorization and reimbursement structure needs substantial reform.
We also need a secure, coordinated system that allows authorized providers to communicate and share appropriate care information, particularly given the high number of individuals who repeatedly access crisis services. This would improve continuity of care, reduce service duplication, strengthen accountability, and help ensure individuals are not repeatedly navigating a fragmented system. Any such system should include appropriate privacy and confidentiality safeguards.
Finally, if MCO authorization remains a requirement, MCO care coordinators must be more actively involved in the crisis response and continuity-of-care process. Providers should not be left to navigate authorization barriers, reimbursement denials, and gaps in care coordination without meaningful support from the organizations responsible for managing these services.
The problems we are experiencing are not simply provider-level issues. They are systemic challenges that begin with the structure, oversight, and administration of the services themselves.
We cannot expect providers to deliver immediate, comprehensive, high-quality crisis care while simultaneously placing administrative and financial barriers in their way.
The priority must be the individual in crisis, the quality of care being delivered, and a system that fairly compensates providers for services appropriately rendered. It is time for meaningful accountability, transparency, and reform.
I would recommend amending the current manual to clarify whether 23-Hour programs, as part of their service provision, may complete pre-admission screenings by qualified staff of a CSB; that this assessment or the assessment with an addendum meets the requirements of a Crisis Assessment; and that locating a facility of temporary detention constitutes care coordination.
Thank you for the chance to comment on the recent changes to Appendix G on services provided under Emergency Custody and Temporary Detention Orders.
Limiting billing to 16 units instead of 32 will put real financial strain on some community services boards. The language limiting billable services to a single 24-hour period is equally concerning. Emergency services programs regularly work with individuals under an ECO or TDO for 72 hours or more, and much of that necessary work would go unreimbursed.
Most importantly, emergency services work doesn't fit well into the mobile crisis billing framework. Pre-admission screening and the statutory duties tied to ECOs and TDOs are a fundamentally different service. This is an opportunity to separate emergency services from the mobile crisis pathway and create a code that reflects that work, or consider the process being billed at a flat rate.
The Crisis Services Unit appreciates the collaborative efforts of DMAS and DBHDS to modernize Virginia's crisis continuum and provide greater clarity regarding the delivery of Mobile Crisis Response (MCR), Community Stabilization, Crisis Stabilization, and Emergency Services. We support the overall goal of strengthening accountability, promoting consistency across providers, and ensuring that crisis services function as an effective pathway into ongoing treatment and recovery supports. We also recognize and support the Commonwealth's efforts to align service definitions and reimbursement requirements with legislative direction. However, we have significant concerns regarding several proposed revisions that may create unintended legal, clinical, and operational consequences for providers and individuals experiencing behavioral health crises.
Our most significant concern relates to the newly proposed limitations governing the duration of a Mobile Crisis Response episode. Specifically, the draft language appears to establish both a four-hour service limit and an effective 24-hour cap on MCR involvement by stating that services shall not be provided beyond the defined episode absent a new qualifying crisis event.
We respectfully request clarification regarding the legal authority for the proposed 24-hour limitation. The 2026 Appropriations Act, Item 291.KKKKK, directed DMAS to "limit mobile crisis services payments to four hours per incident." The language enacted by the General Assembly is specifically directed toward reimbursement and payment. It does not appear to establish a time-limited episode of care, prohibit follow-up activities, restrict care coordination beyond 24 hours, or eliminate the ability of providers to remain engaged while disposition plans are being finalized.
The distinction is critically important. A limitation on payment is not necessarily equivalent to a prohibition on service delivery. The proposed appendix appears to extend far beyond the language adopted by the General Assembly by creating an operational restriction that could terminate all MCR involvement after 24 hours, even when clinically necessary coordination activities remain incomplete. We request clarification regarding the statutory or regulatory authority supporting this expansion beyond the legislative directive and whether the intent is to prohibit reimbursement beyond four hours or prohibit all service-related activities beyond 24 hours.
From an operational perspective, many of the most important crisis intervention activities occur after the initial face-to-face response has concluded. While the crisis may be stabilized within four billable hours, the transition to ongoing services frequently requires additional coordination over subsequent days.
Examples routinely encountered by CSBs include:
Under the proposed language, it is unclear whether these activities could continue once the 24-hour period ends. If the language is interpreted literally, providers may be prohibited from performing the very activities that prevent future crises, emergency department visits, ECOs, TDOs, and hospital admissions.
Ironically, the proposed limitation may have the unintended effect of increasing costs to the Commonwealth by reducing providers' ability to complete successful transitions to care.
For several years, Virginia has invested substantial resources in developing a crisis continuum that emphasizes diversion, care coordination, community-based stabilization, and successful transitions between levels of care.
The proposed 24-hour limitation appears inconsistent with those objectives.
By definition, a crisis continuum depends upon effective handoffs between providers. Limiting the ability of Mobile Crisis teams to remain involved until those handoffs are completed creates a risk that individuals will experience a gap between crisis intervention and ongoing treatment.
We are concerned that providers may be forced into one of two undesirable outcomes:
Neither outcome promotes program integrity or better clinical care.
We respectfully recommend consideration of an alternative approach that preserves the four-hour reimbursement limitation required by the General Assembly while retaining the current ability of providers to conduct non-billable follow-up and care coordination activities over a longer episode period, such as the existing 72-hour framework.
Such an approach would:
Most importantly, it would preserve the ability of crisis providers to ensure that a person who has been stabilized does not become destabilized again simply because the receiving provider, hospital, or stabilization program was unable to complete intake within 24 hours.
We also request clarification regarding the interaction between MCR and Emergency Services activities when a case evolves over several days.
It is common for Mobile Crisis staff to initially attempt diversion and community stabilization; while Emergency Services staff simultaneously monitor clinical status, coordinate with hospitals, communicate with family members, assess alternatives to detention, and continue evaluating risk. These processes frequently unfold over time and rarely fit neatly within a single 24-hour operational window.
If Mobile Crisis involvement must cease after 24 hours, important coordination functions may shift unnecessarily to Emergency Services programs, potentially increasing workload for certified prescreeners and reducing the overall efficiency of the crisis system.
We encourage DMAS and DBHDS to consider whether the proposed language could unintentionally transfer responsibilities among crisis programs rather than reducing utilization.
While we have concerns regarding the episode limitations described above, there are several aspects of the proposed revisions that we strongly support.
The proposed appendix provides a much clearer distinction between Mobile Crisis Response services and Emergency Services/prescreening activities. This clarification should improve consistency across the Commonwealth and reduce longstanding confusion regarding the respective roles of crisis responders and certified prescreeners.
We also strongly support the language prohibiting providers from conditioning access to behavioral health treatment on participation in Mobile Crisis Response or Community Stabilization services. This provision reinforces the principle that crisis services should facilitate access to care rather than function as a gatekeeping mechanism.
Additionally, we view positively the provisions permitting coordination and overlap between local Mobile Crisis teams and Regional Mobile Crisis programs. The flexibility to deploy regional and local resources concurrently when clinically appropriate reflects the realities of crisis service delivery and should improve responsiveness, particularly in rural and underserved regions.
Finally, we support the broader effort to create clearer service definitions, establish more consistent expectations across providers, and strengthen coordination throughout Virginia's crisis continuum.
The proposed reduction from 8 hours (32 units) per 72-hour period to 4 hours (16 units) per 24-hour period has been discussed for some time and was raised again by the ES Council at VACSB. If implemented, this change would reduce our reimbursement for prescreens by half compared to the previous rate. We cannot get multiple authorization codes for the same prescreen even if we are working on the case for multiple days.
On behalf of the Virginia Association of Community-Based Providers (VACBP) and our Crisis Services Council, thank you for the opportunity to comment on the proposed Appendix G update. VACBP supports DMAS’s goals of program integrity, accurate data, and making sure Mobile Crisis Response (MCR) is not used in place of ongoing care. We also support the new provisions that prohibit providers from conditioning access to other services on receipt of crisis services. We understand that the four-hour MCR limit reflects direction in the 2026 Appropriation Act. Our comments focus on implementing these changes so that people in crisis keep access to care and providers have clear, consistent rules.
1. Account for pre-assessment, ECO, placement, and overnight time within the four-hour limit. For adults, the proposed limit is a hard cap of four hours within 24 hours of the start of assessment. An Emergency Custody Order lasts up to eight hours, and teams often remain with the individual while prescreening, medical clearance, bed search, and transport take place. Members report that much of the four hours can pass before the assessment itself begins. That time goes to receiving the dispatch, traveling to the individual (sometimes across jurisdictions), verifying Medicaid eligibility, checking for open authorizations, and completing the consent and intake documentation that DBHDS licensing requires. Once on site, individuals with suicidal ideation or self-harm, psychosis or severe agitation, intoxication or withdrawal, or no safe place to stay often need extended time to build trust, de-escalate, complete a reliable assessment, plan for safety, and find a safe disposition. For an evening or overnight dispatch, the four hours may be used up before community resources open the next morning, which leaves no time for a warm handoff and makes repeat MCR referrals more likely. One member provider reported 130 MCR admissions in October 2026, with 88 percent lasting longer than four hours, and said this share typically ranges from 85 to 90 percent each month. We ask DMAS to (a) clarify whether time spent awaiting ECO/TDO disposition, bed placement, or transport counts toward the cap; (b) because the approved State Plan (SPA 26-0016) allows the four-hour limit to be exceeded only for individuals under 21, consider a future State Plan amendment that creates a documented medical-necessity exception for adults in these circumstances, similar to the EPSDT pathway for youth; and (c) clarify whether travel, eligibility verification, consent, and documentation time count, given that the clock starts when the assessment begins in the crisis data platform. We also ask DMAS to require all MCOs to apply the Appendix G definition of an MCR episode, rather than differing terms such as “per incident” or “per encounter.” Because Community Stabilization also ends on January 1, 2027, individuals who need support beyond four hours will no longer have a follow-on stabilization service. This makes clear rules on what counts toward the four hours, a path to an adult exception, and clear transition pathways more important.
2. Set clear and consistent standards for prepayment review and medical necessity. The draft allows MCOs to conduct prepayment review for overlapping registrations and “frequent utilization,” and to pay only for assessment time when later dispatches are found not medically necessary. Several members report prepayment reviews that have continued since April 2026, well past the 30-day review period they were told to expect. They describe repeated requests for records already submitted, reconsideration requests that receive no response, and medical-necessity denials applied across nearly all claims, in some cases including services other than MCR. One member reported that of roughly 50 claims submitted for review since April, about four had been paid. Members also report reviewers citing Appendix G to deny the full four hours on the grounds that an assessment should not take that long, without accounting for the steps described in point 1. One member was told by an MCO that medical necessity means the individual would deteriorate without immediate care, and was advised to document as if working backward from a completed suicide. Crisis intervention is meant to be preventive. A reviewer reading a record afterward cannot see the individual’s presentation at the time of the crisis, and providers are required to respond to every dispatch under their hub MOUs and regional agreements. We ask DMAS to (a) define “frequent utilization” with a uniform threshold across all MCOs; (b) set and enforce timelines for prepayment determinations and reconsiderations; (c) spell out documentation standards and appeal rights; (d) treat a dispatch made by the regional crisis hub or 988 through the crisis data platform as evidence of medical necessity, since providers do not control dispatch decisions; (e) issue a single medical-necessity standard for MCR that all MCOs must apply, consistent with Appendix G and DBHDS licensing requirements; and (f) require that MCR utilization reviewers have behavioral health crisis experience, and publish the qualifications MCOs must meet. Members report that some reviews are completed by registered nurses without a behavioral health background. Reimbursing only the assessment after a team has responded in good faith shifts the cost of dispatch decisions onto providers, who must pay staff for every hour worked whether or not the claim is paid.
3. Define “provider-generated demand” before making fraud referrals. We support efforts to stop misuse of MCR. Terms such as “standing arrangement,” “recurring schedule,” and “provider-initiated outreach” need definitions that separate abuse from appropriate follow-up and care coordination. Members also describe individuals who learn which statements will prompt a crisis response, sometimes in hopes of shelter, food, or a warm place for a few hours. Providers are still required to respond to these dispatches, and should not bear the financial risk or a fraud referral for doing so. We ask DMAS to (a) confirm that hub-dispatched responses are not provider-initiated; (b) describe the review process and notice providers will receive before a fraud, waste, and abuse referral or a report to DBHDS and the hubs; and (c) clarify that documented attempts at linkage are sufficient when an individual declines services or when no ongoing service is available because of waitlists or limited capacity.
4. Restore the care-coordination exception and clarify team composition. The draft requires every billed team member to be physically present for every unit billed and removes the current exception for a team member who steps away to coordinate care. Bed searches, calls to the MCO, family contacts, and hub communication often need one team member to step aside while the other stays with the individual. Members note that the two staff often work in parallel, with one engaging the individual while the other locates resources, and that overnight many resources are closed, so coordination must continue the next day. We ask DMAS to keep this exception. We also ask DMAS to clarify whether a licensed staff member may still complete a telemedicine-assisted assessment while two QMHPs are on site, or whether the licensed staff member must now be physically present. If a licensed staff member must be on site, team roles change substantially, and the QMHP’s role on the team is reduced. MCOs should not deny payment because an assessment was completed remotely in a manner Appendix G and DBHDS regulations allow. The approved State Plan (SPA 26-0016) defines the MCR assessment as a “face-to-face interaction” provided by an LMHP, LMHP-R, LMHP-RP, or LMHP-S. We ask DMAS to confirm whether “face-to-face” includes a telemedicine-assisted assessment, and to require all MCOs to apply the same interpretation. We also share the workforce concerns other commenters have raised about requiring a second in-person staff member for QMHP-led teams and telemedicine-assisted assessments, especially in rural areas. If the in-person licensed staffing requirements are implemented as written, we believe the suggestion by another commenter that the state take over MCR may be appropriate.
5. Keep the risk-based definition of “behavioral health crisis,” or clarify it. The new definition focuses on an acute change that “exceeds the abilities and resources” of the individual. The current definition includes people “at risk of onset or worsening” of symptoms. Because this definition applies to every crisis service, we ask DMAS to confirm that early intervention to prevent escalation still qualifies, and that MCOs will not use the narrower wording to deny services that met criteria under the current definition.
6. Clarify enrollment requirements, payment for required responses, and the role of CSBs. Please confirm how the requirement for an MOU or contract with “at least one regional crisis hub” aligns with the Appropriation Act’s direction to reimburse providers “contracted with community services boards.” That language is now part of the approved State Plan (SPA 26-0016), effective January 1, 2027. We ask DMAS to state clearly whether a regional crisis hub MOU satisfies the requirement to be “contracted with community services boards,” or whether each provider must hold a direct contract with a CSB, and, if so, with which CSB or CSBs. Members hold hub MOUs, CSB contracts, or both, and these arrangements vary by region. If a provider is required under an MOU or regional agreement to respond whenever it is dispatched, there should be a corresponding obligation to pay for at least a portion of that response. Providers must pay staff for all time worked. Requiring a response and then paying nothing leaves agencies operating at a loss. We also ask DMAS to explain the role CSBs will play in crisis services after these changes, including whether crisis funding will flow through CSBs and whether CSBs will contract with licensed private providers to deliver the service. Finally, a member in Region 3 reports that some providers licensed for MCR and Community Stabilization were not renewed because they were not on a preferred provider list. We ask DMAS and DBHDS to clarify whether such a list exists and how it affects licensing and network participation. Please also give currently enrolled MCR providers a reasonable period to submit licenses and MOUs through the enrollment system without an interruption in payment. If direct CSB contracts are required, we ask for a transition period after January 1, 2027 so that currently enrolled providers can put contracts in place without a gap in payment or in crisis coverage.
7. Allow reimbursement for TDO holding time in 23-Hour Crisis Stabilization. When a TDO is issued after admission, the draft allows the individual to stay on site until transport is arranged but bars additional per diem billing. Programs continue to provide 24-hour nursing, observation, and staffing during this time. Transport delays are beyond the provider’s control, and the services delivered during that time should be covered. We ask DMAS to create a mechanism to pay for this time or to work with DBHDS on timely transport.
8. Coordinate the ECO/TDO Supplement and provide a crosswalk. Prescreening, certified prescreener billing, and concurrent registration provisions have been removed from Appendix G and are now referenced in the ECO/TDO Supplement. We ask DMAS to publish the supplement for comment alongside Appendix G, with a crosswalk showing where each removed provision now lives.
9. Align the effective date with January 1, 2027, and issue guidance first. The planned Appendix G effective date of November 19, 2026, is one day after the comment period closes. CMS approved the MCR changes in SPA 26-0016 with an effective date of January 1, 2027, and MCOs are telling providers the same date. We ask DMAS to make January 1, 2027 the effective date for the MCR provisions, issue its provider bulletin well before that date, and confirm that all MCOs will use the same date and rules.
10. Provide transition guidance and a plan for the gap left by Community Stabilization. CMS approved SPA 26-0015 eliminating Community Stabilization effective January 1, 2027. We ask DMAS to remove or sunset the Community Stabilization section of Appendix G with a clear last date of service (December 31, 2026). We also ask DMAS to set consistent MCO rules for authorizations that span the transition, require MCO care-manager outreach to affected individuals, and identify the services individuals are expected to step down to, especially where capacity is limited. Community Stabilization has served as the bridge between a crisis response and ongoing services. It ends on the same date the MCR limit is cut in half, and during winter, when members typically see crisis calls, hospital use, and homelessness rise. Crisis calls come in around the clock, but outpatient therapy, medication management, and CPST are often not available quickly. Members note that CPST authorizations can take about a week, and shortening that to a few days would not meet the needs of someone leaving a crisis. We ask DMAS to share its plan for individuals who need short-term stabilization after a crisis response, including whether an expedited access pathway or another bridge service will be available.
VACBP and our Crisis Services Council welcome the opportunity to work with DMAS and DBHDS on implementation guidance. Thank you for your consideration.
VACBP respectfully requests DMAS responses to the following questions as implementation guidance is developed.
1.How does the requirement for an MOU or contract with “at least one regional crisis hub” line up with the Appropriation Act’s “contracted with community services boards” language? Will providers with hub MOUs only remain eligible? Now that SPA 26-0016 is approved, will providers need a direct CSB contract by January 1, 2027?
2.Does DMAS intend for CSBs to take over crisis services? Will crisis funding flow through CSBs, and will CSBs contract with approved private providers?
3.What is DMAS’s plan for individuals who need short-term stabilization after a crisis response once Community Stabilization ends?
4.What qualifications must MCO utilization reviewers have to make MCR medical-necessity determinations?
5.Does “face-to-face” assessment in SPA 26-0016 include a telemedicine-assisted assessment?
6.Does the ECO/TDO Supplement have its own open comment forum?
7.Why was the Community Stabilization section updated in the proposed manual if the service ends January 1, 2027? Will it be removed?
8.For DBHDS: Is there a preferred provider list that affects MCR or Community Stabilization license renewals?
Respectfully submitted,
Cate Powell, LCSW
Interim Executive Director
Virginia Association of Community-Based Providers
admin@vacbp.org
Requiring licensed clinicians to provide in-person Mobile Crisis Response (MCR) services will create unintended barriers to care. Qualified Mental Health Professionals (QMHPs) are specifically trained to provide MCR services and have already met rigorous educational and experiential requirements to obtain their credentials. In addition, QMHPs operate under the supervision of licensed professionals, providing an established layer of clinical oversight and accountability.
Given the existing difficulty in filling licensed MCR positions, this proposal would likely reduce the number of available mobile crisis response teams. Fewer teams would mean decreased access to timely, in-person crisis intervention for individuals who meet criteria for Mobile Crisis Response services. Ultimately, this change could limit the ability to meet individuals where they are during a crisis and provide the least restrictive, community-based support.