Virginia Regulatory Town Hall
Agency
Marine Resources Commission
 
Board
Marine Resources Commission
 
chapter
Pertaining to Blue Crab Fishery [4 VAC 20 ‑ 270]

459 comments

All comments for this forum
Page of 10       comments per page    
Next     Back to List of Comments
 
3/14/25  5:59 pm
Commenter: Scott Wivell

I do not support this petition
 

I do not support this petition as it will cause economic hardship for commercial crabbers and is not Based in reality 

CommentID: 233023
 

3/14/25  6:15 pm
Commenter: John Dameron

Crabpots
 

I do not support this petition 

CommentID: 233024
 

3/14/25  6:15 pm
Commenter: Roberta Kellam

Support
 

Thank you. There is no reason to kill turtles while crabbing. 

CommentID: 233025
 

3/14/25  6:16 pm
Commenter: Colie Haydon

I do not support this at all
 

This is ridiculous and I do not support this at all it will cause economic strains on our industry.

CommentID: 233026
 

3/14/25  6:18 pm
Commenter: Daniel Dise. Tangier waterman association

Turtle devices
 

This is a horrible idea.  Waterman do not need any more added expense

CommentID: 233027
 

3/14/25  6:20 pm
Commenter: Tim Merritt

Reduction device
 

I do not support this petition 

CommentID: 233028
 

3/14/25  6:21 pm
Commenter: David Wallace

Turtle excluder
 

I do not support this at all 

CommentID: 233029
 

3/14/25  6:27 pm
Commenter: Zach

Turtle excluder
 

I don’t support this 

CommentID: 233030
 

3/14/25  6:30 pm
Commenter: Tyler lewis

I do not support this petition
 

I do not support this petition. Crabbers already struggle to make a living.

CommentID: 233031
 

3/14/25  6:44 pm
Commenter: Anonymous

No turtle extruders
 

Just no. 

CommentID: 233032
 

3/14/25  6:45 pm
Commenter: Suzanne Conrow

Against this
 

This is a complete waste of money. These turtles do not go near hard crabs. Typically where you see these turtles you would not be able to catch crabs. It is a senseless regulation. 

CommentID: 233033
 

3/14/25  6:45 pm
Commenter: Anonymous

I do not support this at all
 

Would cause immense harm to the blue crab fishery completely detrimental to the men and women who support their families with near shore blue crabbing I do not support this at all

CommentID: 233034
 

3/14/25  6:52 pm
Commenter: Ernest lewis

Petition
 

I do not support petition..i am against it

CommentID: 233035
 

3/14/25  6:57 pm
Commenter: Robert Matthews

Totally against it.
 

Against it. I have never seen any turtles in my pots. 

 

CommentID: 233036
 

3/14/25  7:10 pm
Commenter: Angela

Against Petition
 

Have never had one in any of our pots. 

CommentID: 233037
 

3/14/25  7:12 pm
Commenter: Dennis Dalheim

Oppose this petition
 

I oppose this petition due to lack of evidence to support this claim.

CommentID: 233038
 

3/14/25  7:14 pm
Commenter: Thomas Conrad

Turtle
 

I will not support this at all 

CommentID: 233039
 

3/14/25  7:16 pm
Commenter: Anonymous

Petition
 

I do not support this petition it just adds cost to gear that already cost to much. Don't catch any turtles in the crab pots I've ever worked.souds like someone trying to sell something. They are the ones that probably came up with this nonsense

 

CommentID: 233040
 

3/14/25  7:16 pm
Commenter: ES Resident

Crab pots
 

I am not in favor of this. Stop adding more costly regulations. 

CommentID: 233041
 

3/14/25  7:20 pm
Commenter: Joe Stalgaitis

Against
 

There is no evidence in Maryland that diamondback turtles have rebounded after extruders were enforced. Which should be enough evidence for Virginia. 

CommentID: 233042
 

3/14/25  7:28 pm
Commenter: Thomas Lee Walton, Jr

No Turtle Excluders for commercial crab gear
 

I am opposed to this recommendation for it will put an even further restriction on commercial crabbing which is regulated to death at this point. The device would severely reduce the catch of blue crabs and with license restrictions, many would not be able to sustain the fishery. While I understand the importance of protecting terrapins, this method would create a negative impact on the crabbing industry that far outweighs the positive impacts on the terrapins. Please vote no on this recommendation. 

CommentID: 233043
 

3/14/25  7:34 pm
Commenter: James champion

I do not support
 

I do not support 

CommentID: 233044
 

3/14/25  7:35 pm
Commenter: William Conrad

No Turtle Devices
 

Totally do not support this.

CommentID: 233045
 

3/14/25  7:39 pm
Commenter: Justin johnson

I oppose this petition
 

Not based in reality would be detrimental to the fishery

CommentID: 233046
 

3/14/25  7:41 pm
Commenter: Big city seafood

We oppose this petition
 

We oppose this

CommentID: 233047
 

3/14/25  7:43 pm
Commenter: Anonymous

Do Not Support
 

I do not support this.

I have never caught a turtle in my crabpots.

CommentID: 233048
 

3/14/25  7:46 pm
Commenter: Steven Borst

I do not support this petition
 

I do not support this petition.

CommentID: 233049
 

3/14/25  7:56 pm
Commenter: Douglas Gallagher

Turtle and crab excluder
 

I am against this. It will cost waterman more money. 90 percent of crabs will not want to crawl over the bottom of the turtle excluder . Therefore they will claim there is a decline in crabs .And make even more cuts to finish putting the crabbers out of business! . Not to mention they will fall out of the funnel and be lost . And the river bottom will be full of them for other creatures to get stuck in .  We need to focus on catching crab something that feeds American people. And don’t worry about the turtle.   I guess whoever invented these things is pushing this to line there pockets with sales.  I bet there not a crabber !!  Thanks that’s all folks. 

CommentID: 233050
 

3/14/25  8:03 pm
Commenter: Chesapeake Bay

Reimburse the crab catchers for their lost wages
 

A one time $750,000 payment to the catchers, for their troubles, plus free commission approved crab pots, equaling their total license amount each year. Any new catchers should also get the yearly allotment of approved crab pots/traps, forever... ?? Perpetually free crabpots from the organization, even. Turtle excluders included ??

 

If any of that is approved. 

 

 

CommentID: 233051
 

3/14/25  8:11 pm
Commenter: Bubba Moore

Turtle Excluder.....
 

A foolish endeavor, do not support this proposal

CommentID: 233052
 

3/14/25  8:14 pm
Commenter: Spurgeon Hudgins

Turtle excluder
 

I do not support the  turtle excluder requirement.

CommentID: 233053
 

3/14/25  8:15 pm
Commenter: Travis Smullin

I do not support this
 

This is one of the worst things you can do to a crab pot

CommentID: 233054
 

3/14/25  8:23 pm
Commenter: Raina Simpson

Turtle cull ring
 

I do not support this 

CommentID: 233055
 

3/14/25  8:35 pm
Commenter: Mason carpenter

Crab pot
 

I am against this petition

CommentID: 233062
 

3/14/25  8:35 pm
Commenter: Mason carpenter

Crab pot
 

I am against this petition

CommentID: 233061
 

3/14/25  8:36 pm
Commenter: Teresa Brandt

I do not support this
 

I do not support this

CommentID: 233059
 

3/14/25  8:36 pm
Commenter: Teresa Brandt

I do not support this
 

I do not support this

CommentID: 233058
 

3/14/25  8:36 pm
Commenter: Mason carpenter

Crab pot
 

I am against this petition

CommentID: 233060
 

3/14/25  8:36 pm
Commenter: Teresa Brandt

I do not support this
 

I do not support this

CommentID: 233057
 

3/14/25  8:36 pm
Commenter: Teresa Brandt

I do not support this
 

I do not support this

CommentID: 233056
 

3/14/25  8:37 pm
Commenter: Anonymous

no turtle excluders
 

no turtle excluders

CommentID: 233064
 

3/14/25  8:38 pm
Commenter: Anonymous

no turtle excluders
 

no turtle excluders

CommentID: 233063
 

3/14/25  8:50 pm
Commenter: Anonymous

I don't support this
 

I do not support this 

CommentID: 233065
 

3/14/25  8:55 pm
Commenter: John Setterholm

I do not support this petition
 

I do not support this petition

CommentID: 233066
 

3/14/25  9:02 pm
Commenter: Richard J Murray IV

Against turtle excluder device in crab pots
 

I am against placing turtle excluders in crab pots. They are completely unnecessary. There is little if any scientific data proving that there is an issue with turtles being killed or captured as by catch in commercial crab pots. Commercial fishermen are subjected to many regulations that increase the cost of doing business. This would further increase the cost of doing business with increased supply costs for the excluders as well as increased labor costs to install them. This puts an economic hardship on everyone in an already economically strained industry. All the while with little, to no evidence if they work or if they are necessary. The overwhelming majority of commercial crab pots are set in areas that turtles do not inhabit, therefore making this additional regulation pointless as far as the purpose of having them installed to save turtles.

CommentID: 233067
 

3/14/25  9:03 pm
Commenter: J.B.Davis

No Turtle Excluders Needed!
 

I am speaking for a large number of watermen in the Northern Neck of Virginia. We do not support this petition! The use of turtle excluders as described will only exclude Blue Crabs from the pots, and will be a serious hardship for watermen. We do not see turtles in our pots, so we don't need these excluders to restrict Blue Crabs from being harvested. Thank you.

CommentID: 233068
 

3/14/25  9:07 pm
Commenter: D. R.

No Turtle Excluders needed
 

no turtle excluder needed

CommentID: 233069
 

3/14/25  9:07 pm
Commenter: Jo Downs

I do not support this petition
 

I don't support this petition 

CommentID: 233070
 

3/14/25  9:15 pm
Commenter: Anonymous

Turtle excluder
 

Not needed. 

CommentID: 233071
 

3/14/25  9:22 pm
Commenter: Zach

Turtle excluders are pointless and hurts watermen I don’t support this
 

Turtle excluders are pointless and hurts watermen I don’t support this

CommentID: 233072