I would like to voice my strongest possible objection to mandating the COVID vaccine for all K-12 public and private school employees and students, without allowing religious exemptions, for the following reasons:
1) Comparing this vaccine to other mandatory vaccines (e.g., polio) is comparing apples to oranges. Those shots eliminate the possibility of contracting the disease, while the COVID vaccine is a very narrowly focused and failed attempt, with effectiveness that erodes over time and is proven less effective on the variants. Comparing it to the flu shot is more appropriate...it is optional and even if you get it there is no guarantee that you won't get the flu.
2) This far reaching "big brother" attempt at control will put families at risk when parents lose their jobs for not complying, thus putting the economy into even more of a tailspin. Look at what is happening now at Southwest and American airlines where the pilots are refusing to comply.
3) Removing the religious exemption takes away the religious liberty of families and violates the 1964 Civil Rights Act for those who are sincerely opposed to the vaccine, with no data to prove they are putting anyone at risk.
While I grieve for anyone who has lost a family member to COVID, the reality is that the death rate is 1.6% of the actual cases, but only 13% of the population has had a case, so the actual chance of a fatality to the total population is 1/4 of 1%. Children especially are much less prone to severe symptoms. Why are we destroying our country over those odds?
The "science" on COVID is a moving target as more and more is learned. Now is not the time to take a heavy-handed, dictatorial approach by mandating a vaccine that has proven to be ineffective.