Department of Environmental Quality
State Water Control Board
On this Guidance Document (Virginia Stormwater Management Handbook, Version 1.0)
CLOSED Opened on 2/26/2024 and Ended on 3/27/2024
View all comments
59 comments
| Comment Title | Commenter | |
|---|---|---|
| 1% Rule - Ch 5 Section 5.3.2.1 | Developers Engineers & Contractors, LLC | 3/8/24 12:26 pm |
| 10% Drainage Area - Appendix A, Section A.5.4 | Developers Engineers & Contractors, LLC | 3/8/24 12:30 pm |
| Stormwater Ponds in Open Space. BMP Specifications - Ch 8.5 P-Fil-07, Section 2.1 | Developers Engineers & Contractors, LLC | 3/8/24 12:32 pm |
| Plan Review Timelines – DEQ Example Ordinance (not in handbook) | Developers Engineers & Contractors, LLC | 3/8/24 12:37 pm |
| Maintain the Law’s Max Allowable Pollutant Load - Ch 5 Section 5.3.2.6.1 | Developers Engineers & Contractors, LLC | 3/8/24 12:45 pm |
| Early Grading Plans – Ch 4. Section 4.3.3 | Developers Engineers & Contractors, LLC | 3/8/24 12:53 pm |
| Create a better independent system to alter the handbook’s “living document”. Ch. 1 Section 1.4.2 | Developers Engineers & Contractors, LLC | 3/8/24 12:54 pm |
| Plan Reviewer Dispute Facilitator - Ch 4. Section 4.3.3.1.5 | Developers Engineers & Contractors, LLC | 3/8/24 12:56 pm |
| Create a More Reasonable Performance Bond. DEQ Example Ordinance. | Developers Engineers & Contractors, LLC | 3/8/24 12:59 pm |
| Collecting only Half the Fees at Time of Submittal – Ch. 4 Section 4.3.2.7.1.10 | Developers Engineers & Contractors, LLC | 3/8/24 1:02 pm |
| Phosphorous Load Change. | Greg Lester, Developer | 3/11/24 3:17 pm |
| Performance Bond | Greg Lester, Developer | 3/11/24 3:24 pm |
| Permit Fees | Greg Lester, Developer | 3/11/24 3:25 pm |
| 10% deviation of drainage areas | Sheldon Bower, PE Parker Design Group, Inc | 3/13/24 11:18 am |
| Limits of Analysis and "1% Rule" | Sheldon Bower, PE Parker Design Group, Inc | 3/13/24 11:25 am |
| Natural Channel Definition | Sheldon Bower, PE Parker Design Group, Inc | 3/13/24 11:26 am |
| Maximum Allowable Pollutant Load | Sheldon Bower, PE Parker Design Group, Inc | 3/13/24 11:28 am |
| Support of comments made by Developers, Engineers, & Contractors, LLC | Sheldon Bower, PE Parker Design Group, Inc | 3/13/24 11:29 am |
| Concurrence of comments made by Developers Engineers & Contractors, LLC | Jay Lewis, PE, LS | 3/15/24 2:24 pm |
| A.3.7.2.D Post-Development Curve Number Selection | Lisa Perry, Monteverde Engineering | 3/21/24 9:08 am |
| A.3.7.2 Post-development CN Selection REPEAT Comment | Megan, Kirk Engineering | 3/21/24 2:29 pm |
| Appendix A, Pollutant Load, and Manmade Lakes | Erik Plyler, The Plyler Group | 3/25/24 11:26 am |
| Managed Turf Dominant Projects | Erik Plyler, The Plyler Group | 3/25/24 11:41 am |
| Increasing Development Burden and Costs | Matt Huff, Poe & Cronk Commercial Real Estate Group | 3/25/24 11:53 am |
| Create and independent system to alter the Handbook, Section 1.4.2 | Steve Chisholm, CMC Supply, Inc | 3/26/24 11:19 am |
| Section A.5.4 10% allowance. | Peter Fields Fields Construction, Inc. | 3/26/24 12:07 pm |
| Pollutant load references | Peter Fields Fields Construction, Inc. | 3/26/24 12:10 pm |
| Create independant system to alter the Handbook, Sec. 1.4.2 | Peter Fields Fields Construction, Inc. | 3/26/24 12:19 pm |
| Section 5.3.2.1 and Appendix A Limits of Analysis | Michael Cagle | 3/26/24 1:17 pm |
| Section A.5.4 10% allowance | Michael Cagle | 3/26/24 1:22 pm |
| Section A.5.1.3 Manmade Lakes | Michael Cagle | 3/26/24 1:23 pm |
| Pollutant Load References | Michael Cagle | 3/26/24 1:24 pm |
| Ponds in Open Space – Ch 8.5 P-Fil-07 | Michael Cagle | 3/26/24 1:25 pm |
| Allow Early Grading Plan Approval – Section 4.3.3 | Michael Cagle | 3/26/24 1:25 pm |
| Create an independent system to alter the Handbook, Section 1.4.2 | Michael Cagle | 3/26/24 1:28 pm |
| Clarification on document replacement | Margie Noonan | 3/26/24 1:29 pm |
| Pollutant Load References | Sam Lionberger, Lionberger Construction | 3/26/24 4:37 pm |
| Support of comments made by Developers, Engineers, & Contractors, LLC | Keane Rucker, PE, Shimp Engineering, PC | 3/26/24 5:10 pm |
| Appendix C clarifications | William Sledjeski, PSS, Soil Tech Inc. | 3/26/24 5:29 pm |
| MAREC Action Comments | David Murray, MAREC Action | 3/27/24 10:58 am |
| Clarify where on the project site temporary stabilization requirements apply. (Chapter 6.3.1.5.2) | David Murray, MAREC Action | 3/27/24 11:39 am |
| Available Alternatives in Solar Stormwater Runoff Computations (6.3.1.5.3) | David Murray, MAREC Action | 3/27/24 11:41 am |
| Stow Angle Recommendation in Solar Cell Orientation/Inclination (6.3.1.5.4) | David Murray | 3/27/24 11:42 am |
| Requirements in 6.3.1.5.5 (c) | David Murray, MAREC Action | 3/27/24 11:42 am |
| Panel Spacing Requirement (6.3.1.5.5) (d) | David Murray, MAREC Action | 3/27/24 11:43 am |
| Appendix B - Virginia Runoff Reduction Method (Version 4.1 of the VRRM spreadsheet) | David Murray, MAREC Action | 3/27/24 11:44 am |
| Linear Projects Exclusions for Utility Projects | Trent Warner, Developers Engineers & Contractors, LLC | 3/27/24 11:44 am |
| Section 6.3.1.5.3 & Guidance Memo 22-201 | David Murray, MAREC Action | 3/27/24 2:07 pm |
| Linear Utility Project Exemption | Wayne R. Massie | 3/27/24 2:10 pm |
| Concurrance with prior Commenters | Megan, Kirk Engineering | 3/27/24 3:01 pm |
| Bioretention and Single-Family Homes | Jeff Sledjeski, OSE | 3/27/24 3:35 pm |
| Infiltration and Single-Family Homes | Jeff Sledjeski, OSE | 3/27/24 3:57 pm |
| A.5.6/P-SUP-08 Sheet Flow and Level Spreader Computations REPEAT COMMENT | Megan, Kirk Engineering | 3/27/24 4:14 pm |
| Support for comments presented by Engineers, Developers, and Contractors | Michael Bryant / Hurt &Proffitt | 3/27/24 4:44 pm |
| Concurance with comments | James Kirk, PE, Kirk Engineering PLC | 3/27/24 5:01 pm |
| Technical matters critical to affordable housing in VA | James Taylor, PE; Balzer & Associates | 3/27/24 5:18 pm |
| DEQ Stormwater Management Handbook | Chip Dicks, Gentry Locke | 3/27/24 5:34 pm |
| Section 1.4.2 Handbook Updates and Revisions Process | James Taylor, PE; Balzer & Associates | 3/27/24 7:21 pm |
| Concurrence with Comments - Linear Utility Project Exemption | Rhonda English, BRWA | 3/27/24 8:33 pm |
Trouble posting comments? These pages have been tested with multiple versions of all the major browsers.
If you have trouble: (1) try another computer if you have access to one, (2) try another browser if your computer has one installed (3) contact
Town Hall support staff for assistance.